Skip to main content

Holladay Journal

Hope starts here: Improving mental health in Utah’s paradox

May 06, 2026 12:19PM ● By Collette Hayes

A 2026 WalletHub report ranks Utah as the sixth-happiest state in the nation, which might suggest that residents generally experience favorable mental health. Regardless of Utah’s high happiness ranking, research also shows that residents face significant challenges to their emotional and physical well-being. The Utah Women & Leadership Project at Utah State University reports that Utah has the second-highest percentage of adults living with mental illness (29.9%), following Oregon (30.2%), indicating mental health remains a pressing concern.

Dr. Anthony Petersen, a board certified psychiatrist and Utah native, studied at the University of Utah and is now accepting new patients at Serenity Mental Health Centers clinic in Holladay. Having lived in Utah his entire life, he brings clinical expertise and firsthand understanding of the Utah communities’ mental health needs.

As a psychiatrist practicing in Utah, he has observed the paradox that Utah ranks among the “happiest” states in some areas while having higher-than-average rates of mental health conditions. The WalletHub report identified Utah’s work and community metrics as sources of happiness, including strong community ties, high volunteer rates and high employment rates. Peterson points out additional factors that contribute to higher mental health condition rates across the state. He references a 2025 Utah State University report that found 32.5% of Utah women have been diagnosed with depression, compared to 19.5% of men. Utah children also have higher-than-average exposure to Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs), ranking seventh in the nation. ACE exposure is strongly linked to long-term behavioral health issues.

“Utah is part of a geographical region often referred to as the 'suicide belt,’” Petersen said. “Contributing factors often discussed include the impact of high elevation and rural isolation. Despite the high prevalence of mental illness, Utah faces significant hurdles in treatment. The state has a high rate of adults reporting an unmet need for mental health treatment. Stigma surrounding mental health, particularly in tight-knit communities, often leads to delayed treatment, making conditions more severe by the time a person seeks help.”

Factors contributing to the rise in mental health concerns among youth

According to Petersen, the high rate of ACEs prime children for sensitivity to mental health problems as they age. These experiences include physical, emotional and sexual abuse; physical and emotional neglect; parental separation or divorce; exposure to domestic violence; and living with household members who are incarcerated, mentally ill or have a substance use disorder.

The 2023 SHARP survey in Utah collected data from 52,000 students statewide regarding their screen time usage. Nearly 80% (79.8%) of students reported spending two or more hours per day on screens, excluding school-related activities, an increase from 66.7% in 2019. The findings also indicated a strong association between increased screen time and insufficient sleep, suicidal ideation and substance use.

“The recent Utah survey data indicate a significant percentage of youth spend excessive time on screens, correlating with declining mental health, disrupted sleep and lower engagement in person-to-person social activities,” Petersen said. “Adolescent women are particularly vulnerable to these pressures.”

Petersen continued, “As a state with strong religious and familial cultural expectations, many Utah youth feel immense pressure to achieve high standards, ranging from academic performance to rigid moral perfectionism. When they fall short, feelings of shame, inadequacy and ‘not being enough’ contribute to rising anxiety and hopelessness.”

Beginning steps to explore mental health treatment

The National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) reports that treatment options such as therapy, medication and self-care have helped many people recover from mental health concerns. Although starting treatment may feel confusing or challenging, Petersen recommends these steps to begin seeking mental health support:

1. Start with self-awareness about your needs, goals and overall well-being. Spend time defining your own mental health needs. If your symptoms interfere with daily life (work, sleep, relationships) or if you are struggling with persistent anxiety or depression, it is time to seek help.

2. If your mental health is reaching a crisis point, reach out for emergency assistance. Utah has robust crisis services that can act as a front door to treatment, helping to stabilize the emergency and establishing follow-up care to continue after. The 988-crisis line offers free, confidential support.

3. Be consistent and patient while searching for a provider. Finding a provider in Utah requires persistence due to high demand. Start by contacting your insurer for a list of in-network providers to reduce costs. Online platforms like Psychology Today, SAMHSA treatment locator, or Utah specific mental health directories are helpful. Serenity Mental Health Centers is actively accepting new patients across Salt Lake City.

 4. Make the most of your first appointment by being prepared. Write down a summary of your symptoms, family history and current medications. Ask questions to ensure the provider is a good fit for you and your symptoms. The most important indicator of success is feeling understood and comfortable with the provider.

5. Outside of your time with your mental health provider, make sure you’re taking good care of yourself and utilizing available support. Engage in peer support groups, such as those sponsored by NAMI Utah. Simple daily routines, such as consistent sleep schedules, can create stability.

Environmental or health-related factors, whether mental or physical, can initially trigger the onset of mental illness

Approximately 75% of mental health conditions appear by age 24. However, age is not the only factor. Environmental and health-related influences, often interacting with genetic predisposition, can activate underlying vulnerabilities and lead to mental illness. Peterson also identifies additional factors that may trigger the onset of a mental health condition.

“Poverty, debt and unemployment contribute to chronic environmental stress,” Petersen said. “This stress can trigger mental illness and perpetuate a difficult cycle to break. Physical, sexual or emotional abuse, especially during childhood, significantly increases the risk of developing PTSD, depression or personality disorders later in life. The death of a loved one, divorce or major relationship breakups are also significant triggers, often resulting in severe depressive or anxiety disorders. Long-term or heavy use of alcohol, marijuana or illicit drugs can directly trigger mental health conditions such as psychosis, anxiety and depression by altering brain chemistry.”

Petersen continues, “Living with chronic, painful or debilitating diseases frequently triggers depression or anxiety. Persistent lack of sleep is not only a symptom of poor mental health but also a major trigger, disrupting neurochemistry and increasing emotional reactivity.”

 Promising developments or sources of hope for individuals living with mental illness.

According to Petersen, the Utah landscape of mental health care in 2026 is rapidly evolving to be more accessible, personalized and proactive. Utah is actively addressing the confusion and challenge of entry points, particularly for crisis services. Utah is heavily investing in expanding Mobile Crisis Outreach Teams (MCOTs) and rural receiving centers. These teams bring a mental health professional and a peer support specialist directly to the person in crisis, aiming to de-escalate without involving law enforcement. The state is investing in The Center for School Health and Wellbeing partnerships to integrate mental health screenings and services directly into schools, helping youth and families find help early.

For treatment-resistant conditions, new, faster-acting options are being developed. NMDA-targeting options like ketamine infusion therapy can provide relief within days, not weeks, for those who haven’t responded to traditional antidepressants. Research into Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) shows increasingly positive results for the treatment of chronic mental health conditions that medications have not benefited.  

Serenity Mental Health Centers, which has four mental health clinics across the Wasatch Front, is actively expanding its locations and outpatient services to meet the extensive need for mental health care. Petersen has recently relocated his medical practice and is accepting new patients at the Serenity Mental Health Centers clinic in Holladay.

“The biggest source of hope for those living with mental illness is that the focus is shifting from reactive crisis care to proactive, preventive support,” Petersen said. “As a psychiatrist, I can tell you that the stigma is lessening, and options are expanding. If a previous treatment didn’t work, it doesn't mean the patient is ‘broken’—it often means the right, modern tool just wasn’t available yet.”  

If you are in need of immediate emotional support, call the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

If you would like further information about the Serenity Mental Health Centers clinic in Holladay or Dr. Anthony Peterson call 801-754-6032 or visit the Serenity Mental Health Care Centers website: www.serenitymentalhealthcenters.com/utah-psychiatry-clinics/